MINNESOTA COMPASSIONATE CARE
ACT OF 2015
SF 1880
The text below the horizontal line is the text of Senate File 1880,
as downloaded from the State of Minnesota website on March 18, 2015.
Nothing has been changed in the
text.
Line divisions have been
modified
to make this bill easier to
read on computer screens.
And links to external
safeguards have been added.
These added explanations on
the Internet are NOT
part of the bill.
An organized list of these embedded
safeguards
appears after the end of the text.
And finally, there are a few
critical comments at the end.
A
bill for an act
relating to health; adopting compassionate
care for terminally ill patients;
proposing coding for new law in
Minnesota Statutes, chapter 145.
BE IT
ENACTED BY THE LEGISLATURE OF THE STATE OF MINNESOTA:
This section may be cited as the "Minnesota Compassionate Care Act of 2015."
(a) For purposes of this section, the following terms have the meanings given.
(b) "Adult" means a person who is 18 years of age or older.
(c)
"Aid in dying" means the medical practice of a physician
prescribing medication to a qualified patient who is terminally
ill,
which medication a qualified patient may self-administer to bring about
the patient's own death.
(d)
"Attending physician" means the physician who has primary
responsibility
for the medical care of the patient and treatment of the patient's
terminal illness.
(e)
"Competent" means, in the opinion of the patient's attending
physician,
consulting physician, psychiatrist,
psychologist, or a court,
that the patient has the capacity to understand and acknowledge
the nature and consequences of health care decisions,
including the benefits and disadvantages of treatment,
to make an informed decision and to communicate the decision to a
health care provider,
including communicating through a person familiar with the patient's
manner of communicating.
(f)
"Consulting physician" means a physician who is qualified by specialty
or experience
to make a professional diagnosis and prognosis regarding the patient's
terminal illness.
(g)
"Counseling" means one or more consultations as necessary
between a psychiatrist
or a psychologist and a patient
for the purpose of determining that the patient is competent
and not suffering from depression
or any other psychiatric or psychological disorder that causes impaired
judgment.
(h)
"Health care provider" means a person licensed, certified,
or otherwise authorized or permitted by law to administer health care
or dispense medication in the ordinary course of business or practice
of a profession,
including but not limited to a physician, psychiatrist, psychologist,
or pharmacist.
(i) "Health care facility" means a hospital, residential care home, nursing home, or rest home.
(j) "Informed
decision" means a decision by a qualified patient
to request and obtain a prescription for medication
that the qualified patient may self-administer for aid in dying,
that is based on an understanding and acknowledgment of the relevant
facts
and after being fully informed by the attending physician of:
(1) the patient's medical diagnosis and prognosis;
(2) the potential risks associated with self-administering the medication to be prescribed;
(3) the probable result of taking the medication to be prescribed;
(4) the
feasible
alternatives and health care treatment options,
including but not limited to palliative care.
(k)
"Medically confirmed" means the medical opinion of the attending
physician
has been confirmed by a consulting
physician
who has examined the patient and the patient's relevant medical records.
(l)
"Palliative care" means health care centered on a terminally ill
patient
and the patient's family that:
(1)
optimizes the patient's quality of life
by anticipating, preventing, and treating the patient's suffering
throughout the continuum of the patient's terminal illness;
(2) addresses the physical, emotional, social, and spiritual needs of the patient;
(3)
facilitates patient autonomy, the patient's access to information,
and patient choice; and
(4)
includes but is not limited to discussions
between the patient and a health care provider
concerning the patient's goals for treatment options available to the
patient,
including hospice care and comprehensive pain and symptom management.
(m) "Patient" means a person who is under the care of a physician.
(n) "Pharmacist" means a person licensed under chapter 151.
(o) "Physician" means a person licensed to practice medicine and surgery under chapter 147.
(p) "Psychiatrist" means a psychiatrist licensed under chapter 147.
(q) "Psychologist" means a psychologist licensed under section 148.907.
(r)
"Qualified patient" means a competent adult
who is a
resident of Minnesota,
has a terminal
illness,
and has satisfied the requirements of this section in order to obtain
aid in dying.
(s) "Self-administer" means a qualified patient's act of ingesting medication.
(t) "Terminal
illness"
means the final stage
of an incurable and irreversible medical condition
that an attending physician anticipates, within reasonable medical
judgment,
will produce a patient's death within six months.
(a) A person who:
(1) is an adult;
(2) is competent;
(3) is a resident of Minnesota;
(4) has
been determined by the person's attending physician
to have a terminal
illness; and
(5) has voluntarily expressed a wish to receive aid in dying
may request aid in dying by making two written requests pursuant to subdivisions 4 and 5.
(b) A
person is not a qualified patient under this section
based solely on age, disability, or any specific illness.
(c) No
person, including but not limited to
an agent under a living will, an attorney-in-fact under a durable power
of attorney,
a guardian, or a conservator,
may
act on
behalf of a patient for purposes of this section.
(a) A
patient wishing to receive aid in dying
shall submit two
written requests to the patient's attending physician
in substantially the form in subdivision 5.
A valid written request for aid in dying under this section
shall be signed and dated by the patient.
Each request shall be witnessed by at least two persons
who, in the presence of the patient,
attest that to the best of their knowledge and belief the patient is:
(1) of sound mind; and
(2) acting voluntarily and not being coerced to sign the request.
The patient's second written request for aid in dying
shall be submitted no
earlier than
15 days after the patient submits the first request.
(b) At
least one of the witnesses described in paragraph
(a) shall be a person who is not:
(1) a relative of the patient by blood, marriage, or adoption;
(2) at the time the request is signed,
entitled to any portion of the estate of the patient upon the patient's
death,
under any will or by operation of law; or
(3) an owner, operator, or employee of a health care facility
where the patient is receiving medical treatment or is a resident.
(c) The
patient's attending physician at the time the request is signed
shall not be a witness.
(d) If
the patient is a resident of a residential care home,
nursing home, or skilled nursing facility at the time the written
request is made,
one of the witnesses shall be a person designated by the home or
facility.
A request
for aid
in dying as authorized by this section
shall be in substantially the following form:
REQUEST FOR MEDICATION TO AID IN DYING
I, ......., am an adult of sound mind.
I am
suffering from ......., which my attending physician has determined
is an incurable
and irreversible medical condition
that will, within reasonable medical judgment, result in death within
six months.
This diagnosis of a terminal
illness
has been confirmed by another
physician.
I have
been fully informed
of my diagnosis, prognosis,
the nature of medication to be prescribed to aid me in dying,
the potential associated risks, the expected result, feasible
alternatives,
and additional
health care treatment options, including palliative care.
I
request that my attending physician prescribe medication
that I
may
self-administer for aid in dying.
I authorize my attending physician to contact a pharmacist
to fill the prescription for the medication, upon my request.
INITIAL ONE:
.......
I have informed
my family of my decision
and taken their opinions into consideration.
....... I have decided not to inform my family of my decision.
....... I have no family to inform of my decision.
I understand that I have the right to rescind this request at any time.
I
understand the full import of this request
and I expect to die if and when I take the medication to be prescribed.
I further understand that although most deaths occur within three
hours,
my death may take longer
and my attending physician has counseled me about this possibility.
I make
this request
voluntarily and without reservation,
and I accept full responsibility for my decision to request aid in
dying.
Signed: .......
Dated: .......
DECLARATION OF WITNESSES
By
initialing and signing below on the date the person named above signs,
I declare that the person making and signing the above request:
Witness 1 ....... Witness 2 .......
Initials ........ Initials .......
....... 1. Is personally known to me or has provided proof of identity;
....... 2. Signed this request in my presence on the date of the person's signature;
....... 3. Appears to be of sound mind and not under duress, fraud, or undue influence; and
....... 4. Is not a patient for whom I am the attending physician.
Printed Name of Witness 1 ..............
Signature of Witness 1 ................ Date ...............
Printed Name of Witness 2 ...............
Signature
of Witness 2 ................. Date .......
(a) A
qualified patient may rescind
the
patient's request for aid in dying
at any time and in any manner without regard to the patient's mental
state.
(b) An
attending physician shall offer a qualified patient
an opportunity to rescind the patient's request for aid in dying
at the time the patient submits a second written request
for aid in dying to the attending physician.
(c) No
prescription for medication for aid in dying shall be written
without the qualified patient's attending physician first offering the
qualified patient
a
second
opportunity to rescind the patient's request for aid in dying.
When an
attending physician is presented with a patient's first written request
for aid in dying under this section, the attending physician shall:
(1) make a determination that the patient:
(i) is an adult;
(ii) has a terminal illness;
(iii) is competent; and
(iv) has voluntarily requested aid in dying;
(2) require the patient to demonstrate residency in this state by presenting:
(i) Minnesota driver's license;
(ii) a valid voter registration record authorizing the patient to vote in this state;
(iii) evidence that the patient owns or leases property in this state; or
(iv)
any other government-issued document
that the attending physician reasonably believes
demonstrates that the
patient is
a current resident of this state;
(3) ensure that the patient is making an informed decision by informing the patient of:
(i) the patient's medical diagnosis;
(ii) the patient's prognosis;
(iii)
the potential risks associated with self-administering the medication
to be prescribed for aid in dying;
(iv)
the probable result of self-administering the medication
to be prescribed for aid in dying; and
(v) the
feasible
alternatives and health care treatment options
including, but not limited to, palliative care; and
(4)
refer the patient to a consulting
physician
for medical confirmation of the attending physician's
diagnosis of the patient's terminal
illness,
the patient's
prognosis,
and for a determination that the patient is competent
and acting
voluntarily in requesting aid in dying.
In
order for a patient to be found to be a qualified patient
for the purposes of this section, a consulting
physician shall:
(1) examine the patient and the patient's relevant medical records;
(2)
confirm, in writing, the attending physician's diagnosis
that the patient has a terminal
illness;
(3)
verify that the patient is competent,
is
acting voluntarily,
and has made an informed
decision to request aid in dying; and
(4)
refer the patient for counseling, if required in accordance with
subdivision 9.
(a) If,
in the medical opinion
of the attending physician or the consulting physician,
a patient may
be suffering from a psychiatric or psychological condition
or depression that is causing
impaired judgment,
either the attending or consulting physician
shall
refer the
patient
for counseling
to determine whether the patient is competent to request aid in dying.
(b) An
attending physician shall not provide the patient aid in dying
until
the person providing the counseling determines
that the patient is not suffering a
psychiatric or psychological condition
or depression that is causing impaired judgment.
(a)
After an attending physician and a consulting physician determine
that a patient is a qualified patient,
and after the
qualified patient submits a
second request
for aid in dying
according to subdivision 4, the
attending physician shall:
(1)
recommend to the qualified patient
that the patient notify
the
patient's next of kin of the patient's request for aid in dying
and inform the qualified
patient that failure to do so
shall not be a basis for the denial of the request;
(2) counsel the qualified patient concerning the importance of:
(i)
having another person present
when the qualified patient
self-administers
the medication prescribed for aid in dying; and
(ii) not taking the medication in a public place;
(3)
inform the qualified patient that the patient may
rescind
the patient's
request for aid in dying at any time and in any manner;
(4)
verify, immediately before writing the prescription for medication for
aid in dying,
that the qualified patient is making an informed
decision;
(5) fulfill the medical record documentation requirements in subdivision 11; and
(6)(i)
dispense
medications, including ancillary medications
intended to
facilitate the desired effect to minimize the qualified patient's
discomfort,
if the
attending physician is authorized to dispense such medication,
to the qualified patient; or
(ii) upon the qualified patient's request and with the qualified patient's written consent;
(A) contact a pharmacist and inform the pharmacist of the prescription; and
(B)
deliver the written prescription personally,
by mail, by facsimile, or
by another electronic method
that is permitted by the pharmacy to the pharmacist,
who shall dispense the medications directly to the qualified patient,
the attending
physician,
or an expressly identified agent of the qualified patient.
(b) The
attending physician may sign the qualified patient's death certificate
that shall list the underlying terminal illness as the cause of death.
With
respect to a request by a qualified patient for aid in dying,
the attending physician shall ensure that the following items
are documented or filed in the qualified patient's medical record:
(1) the
basis for determining that the qualified patient requesting aid in
dying
is
an adult
and is a resident of the state;
(2) all oral requests by a qualified patient for medication for aid in dying;
(3) all written requests by a qualified patient for medication for aid in dying;
(4) the
attending
physician's diagnosis of the qualified patient's terminal
illness and prognosis,
and a determination that the qualified patient is competent,
is acting voluntarily, and has made an informed
decision to request aid in dying;
(5) the
consulting
physician's confirmation of the qualified patient's
diagnosis and prognosis,
and confirmation that the qualified patient is competent,
is
acting voluntarily, and has made an informed
decision to request aid in dying;
(6) a
report of the outcome and determinations made during counseling,
if
counseling was recommended and provided as required by subdivision 9;
(7)
documentation of the attending physician's offer to the qualified
patient
to
rescind
the patient's request for aid in dying
at the time the attending
physician writes the qualified patient
a prescription for medication for aid in dying; and
(8) a
statement by the attending physician
indicating that all requirements
under this section have been met
and indicating the steps taken to carry out the
qualified patient's request for aid in dying,
including the medication prescribed.
Records
or information collected or maintained under this section
shall not be subject to subpoena or discovery or
introduced into evidence
in any judicial or administrative proceeding
except to resolve matters
concerning compliance with this section,
or as otherwise specifically provided by law.
Any
person in possession of medication prescribed for aid in dying
that has not been self-administered must
dispose of the medication.
(a) Any
provision in a contract, will, insurance policy, annuity, or other
agreement,
whether written or
oral, that is entered into on or after October 1, 2015,
that would affect whether a person
may make or rescind
a request for aid in dying is not valid.
(b) Any
obligation owing under any currently existing contract
shall not
be conditioned or affected by
the making or rescinding of a request for
aid in dying.
(c) On
and after the effective date of this section,
the sale, procurement, or
issuance of any life, health, or accident insurance
or annuity policy or the
rate charged for any such policy
shall not be conditioned upon or affected
by the making or
rescinding of a request for aid in dying.
(d) A
qualified patient's act of requesting aid in dying
or
self-administering medication prescribed for aid in dying shall not:
(1)
affect a life, health, or accident insurance or annuity policy,
or
benefits payable under the policy;
(2) be
grounds for eviction from a person's place of residence
or a basis
for discrimination in the terms, conditions, or privileges of sale or
rental
of a dwelling or in the provision of services or facilities
because of the patient's
request for aid in dying;
(3) provide the sole basis for the appointment of a conservator or guardian; or
(4)
constitute suicide for any purpose.
(a) As
used in this section, "participate in the provision of medication"
means to perform the
duties of an attending physician or consulting physician,
a psychiatrist, a psychologist, or a
pharmacist according
to subdivisions 2 to 10, and does not include:
(1) making an initial diagnosis of a patient's terminal illness;
(2) informing a patient of the patient's medical diagnosis or prognosis;
(3)
informing a patient concerning the provisions of this section,
upon the
patient's request; or
(4) referring a patient to another health care provider for aid in dying.
(b)
Participation in any act described in this section
by a patient, health
care provider, or any other person shall be voluntary.
Each health care provider shall
individually and affirmatively determine
whether to participate in the provision of
medication
to a qualified patient for aid in dying.
A health care facility shall not require a
health care provider to participate
in the provision of medication to a qualified patient for
aid in dying,
but may prohibit such participation according to paragraph (d).
(c) If
a health care provider or health care facility is unwilling to
participate
in the provision of medication to a qualified patient for aid in dying,
the
health care provider or health care facility
shall transfer all relevant medical records
to
a health care provider or health care facility as requested by a
qualified patient.
(d) A
health care facility may adopt written policies
prohibiting a health
care provider associated with the health care facility
from participating in
the provision of medication to a patient for aid in dying,
provided the facility
provides written notice of the policy
and any sanctions for violation of the policy to the
health care provider.
Notwithstanding the provisions of this paragraph
or any policies
adopted according to this paragraph,
a qualified health care provider may:
(1) diagnose a patient with a terminal illness;
(2) inform a patient of the patient's medical prognosis;
(3)
provide a patient with information concerning the provisions of this
section,
upon a patient's request;
(4) refer a patient to another health care facility or health care provider;
(5)
transfer a patient's medical records to a health care provider
or
health care facility as requested by a patient; or
(6)
participate in the provision of medication for aid in dying
when the
health care provider is acting outside the scope
of the provider's employment or
contract with a health care facility
that prohibits participation in the provision of the
medication.
(a) Any
person who without authorization of a patient
willfully alters or forges a request for aid in dying, as described in
subdivisions 4 and 5,
or conceals or destroys a rescission of a request for aid in dying
with
the intent or effect of causing the patient's death,
is
guilty of
attempted murder or murder.
(b) Any
person who coerces or exerts undue influence
on a patient to complete
a request for aid in dying,
as described in subdivisions 4 and 5,
or
coerces or exerts undue influence on a patient
to destroy a rescission of the request
with the
intent or effect of causing the patient's death,
is
guilty of
attempted murder or murder.
(a)
Nothing in this section authorizes a physician or any other person
to end a patient's life by lethal injection, mercy
killing, assisting a suicide,
or any other active euthanasia.
(b) Any
action taken according to this section
does not constitute causing or
assisting another person to commit suicide.
(c) No
report of a public agency may refer to the practice
of obtaining
and self-administering life-ending medication
to end a qualified patient's
life as "suicide" or "assisted suicide,"
and shall refer to the practice as "aid in dying."
This
section does not limit liability for civil damages
resulting from negligent conduct or intentional misconduct by any
person.
Nothing
in this section precludes criminal prosecution
under any provision of law for conduct that is inconsistent
with this section.
SAFEGUARDS
EMBEDDED IN MINNESOTA'S COMPASSIONATE CARE BILL of 2015
The Minnesota
safeguards are listed
below.
Each is linked to a complete
explanation on the Internet.
These explanations are not
included in the proposed law.
But further discussion of any of these proposed safeguards
might benefit from the full explanation on the Internet.
SAFEGUARD
B Requests
for
Death from the Patient
SAFEGUARD C Psychological
Consultant Evaluates the Patient's
Ability to Make Medical Decisions
SAFEGUARD D Physician's
Statement of Condition and Prognosis
SAFEGUARD E Independent
Physician Reviews the Condition and
Prognosis
SAFEGUARD F Certification
of Terminal Illness or Incurable
Condition
SAFEGUARD
J Informed
Consent from the Patient
SAFEGUARD
T Civil
and
Criminal Penalties for Causing Premature Death
SAFEGUARD U Waiting
Periods
For Reflection
SAFEGUARD V Opportunities
for the Patient to Rescind or Postpone the
Life-Ending Decision
SAFEGUARD
Y The
Patient
Must Be Conscious and Able to Achieve
Death
SAFEGUARD Z The
Death-Planning Coordinator Organizes the
Safeguards
SAFEGUARD AA Information
about
Palliative Care and other Alternatives to Death
SAFEGUARD BB Notify
Family of
Life-Ending Decision
SAFEGUARD
DD The
Patient
Must be an Adult Resident of the State
SAFEGUARD
EE Physician
Agrees
to Provide Life-Ending Chemicals
By this count,
15 different
safeguards are included in Minnesota's proposed law.
These safeguards keep their
letters from the complete list of 26
recommended
safeguards.
And the four with double
letters are additional possible safeguards.
All safeguards are discussed
in this book: How
to Die:
Safeguards for Life-Ending Decisions.
These safeguards are mentioned 73 times in SF 1880 above.
COMMENTS ON THIS PROPOSED LAW
FOR THE STATE OF MINNESOTA
by James Leonard Park
Careful thought
has gone into the creation of this proposed law.
It draws on several earlier attempts to create such laws.
And it has omitted most of the technical problems of other
formulations.
Under existing
Minnesota law, doctors and health-care proxies
are permitted to choose any combination of the following medical methods of managing
dying:
(1) increasing
pain-medication, even if this will shorten the process
of dying;
(2) beginning terminal
sedation, which will keep the patient
unconscious until death;
(3) withdrawing
or withholding medical treatments and/or life-supports;
&
(4) giving
up
food and water.
These life-ending decisions are permitted even if the patient is in a coma.
SF 1880 makes no
advances over other similar laws,
which have been used for only 1-3 deaths out of a 1,000.
Quebec's right-to-die law will cover 10 times as many deaths
because it also names other methods of choosing death
such as "terminal palliative sedation" and terminating life-supports:
http://www.tc.umn.edu/~parkx032/SG-QUEB.html.
This bill will
definitely be supported by all liberal members of the Minnesota
legislature.
But there are no new
provisions or additional,
unusual safeguards
that would attract the votes of legislators who are more conservative.
When the
Minnesota legislature ended its 2015 term in June, 2015,
almost no action had been taken on this bill.
In March 2016, the Senate committee held a public hearing,
after which the sponsors withdrew the bill from consideration.
A new bill will be introduced in 2017.
However, this
offers a
good opportunity to add more safeguards,
especially protections for vulnerable patients,
which would improve the chances of such legislation
passing both houses of the Minnesota legislature.
Here are five
additional safeguards that would make the law better
and that will win a few more votes from conservative lawmakers:
S. REVIEW
BY THE
PROSECUTOR (OR OTHER LAWYER)
BEFORE
THE DEATH
TAKES PLACE