Copyright © 2018 by James Leonard Park
Selected and reviewed
by James Park.
The books are organized by quality, beginning
with the best.
Red comments are the
opinions of this reviewer.
1.
Leslie Feinberg
Transgender
Warriors:
Making
History from Joan of Arc to RuPaul
(Boston, MA: Beacon Press,
1996) 212 pages
(ISBN: 0807079405; hardback)
(Library of Congress call number: HQ77.9.F45
1996)
Transgender
Warriors:
Making
History from Joan of Arc to Dennis Rodman
(Boston, MA: Beacon Press,
1997) 218 pages
(ISBN: 0807079413; paperback)
(Library of Congress call number: HQ77.9.F44
1996)
This book embraces
several variations of sex and gender:
(in order of importance) transsexuals;
homosexuals; cross-dressers;
intersexuals; people with unusual gender-personalities;
and people who transcend conventional
sex-roles.
All of these are called
"transgender"
persons.
But this term is mainly useful for
the
political project
of winning civil rights for
persons with
such variations.
Scientifically, the term
"transgender"
is far too broad and vague
because it lumps all variations of
sex
and gender together,
without regard to the causes or
reasons
behind each variation.
(This book casts no light on such
possible
causes or reasons.)
The fundamental
purposes of this collection
of pictures, stories, and myths of 'transgender'
people
is to build a positive image (and self-image)
of all variations of sex and gender.
The author has combed history and pre-history,
looking for positive stories about people
(and gods)
with some variation from standard sex
and gender:
myths from the major cultures of the
world;
indigenous peoples of the New World;
Roman Catholic saints; modern history.
Feinberg also explores tolerance and
intolerance
of such variations around the world.
Leslie Feinberg might
like to be referred to as "he"
in any review of this book,
but the present reviewer, knowing
her
only thru the printed word,
feels that she is more a strong
woman
in personality than a man.
The author was born female but now lives
as a man.
(For more details, read the book.)
The facts of her own life do not
distort
what she reports
—except in her selection of only
positive
role-models—
but her interest in the subject
was doubtless
personal.
Transgender
Warriors is not an
objective history
of people with variations of sex
and
gender.
Only positive examples and stories
are
included.
All the 'transgendered' people who
suffered
internally
or even killed themselves are
omitted.
The only suffering acknowledged
here
is caused by other people
and authorities, who oppressed
everyone
who did not fit the standard
patterns
of sex and gender.
But the purpose of the book is to
present
positive role-models,
not to present all sides of
'transgenderism'.
The author wants to make the world safer
for all variations of sex and gender.
People should not have to classify themselves
by sex or gender.
And they should not have to follow life-paths
dictated by such classifications.
Feinberg seems to believe that sex
and
gender are free choices.
And we should all have the civil
right
to live any way we please.
Transgender
Warriors is richly
illustrated
with pictures on almost every page.
And the last section is over 30 pages
of pictures and stories
of contemporary 'transgender' people.
For years to
come, this book will be a rich source
of stories and descriptions of
variations
of sex and gender.
Next, we need some careful,
scientific
analysis
of all phenomena related to sex
and gender—and
their variations.
2.
Holly Devor
FTM:
Female-to-Male
Transsexuals in Society
(Bloomington, IN: Indiana
University Press,
1997) 695 pages
(ISBN: 0-253-33631-7; hardback)
(ISBN: 0-253-21259-6; paperback, 1999)
(Library of Congress call number: HQ77.9.D49
1997)
Careful sociologist,
Holly Devor, interviewed 45 individuals
who were born as normal females but who
later decided to become men
—socially, hormonally, & sometimes
surgically.
She begins her
book with an historical review
of women who lived as men
long before sex-changes or transsexualism
were invented.
These women had many different reasons
for living as men.
FTM
contains several stunning pictures
of people who would always be taken for
men:
beards, male-pattern balding, muscles,
etc.
But all of these people were born female
and later changed to men.
It is very hard to believe that these
people ever lived as women
—or that they still have female genitals,
which is usually the case.
Real first names are given with these
pictures.
But
in order to protect
their privacy,
the participants in this study were all
given pseudonyms.
Thus it is not possible to connect the
pictures with the stories.
The author informs me that some
of the participants are pictured.
Maybe a follow-up book, two
decades into
the 21 century,
would find the participants more
willing
to have their pictures used along
with
their stories.
Some books on transsexuals do
include
'before' and 'after' pictures
of the individuals who have
changed sex.
Devor does not
endorse any single theory
of why some people want to change sex.
She reviews the scientific theories
but remains open to newer explanations
that might emerge in the future.
The participants showed a variety of
pathways to becoming men.
Some decided relatively late in life,
whereas others knew from an early age
that they wanted to be male.
Family background does not provide a
comprehensive explanation.
But it is an obvious place to begin looking.
Holly Devor spends quite a few pages
exploring
the family backgrounds of the participants.
However, dysfunctional families
are very
common everywhere.
And most families-with-problems do
not
produce children
who want to change sex in
adulthood.
Additional factors beyond
alcoholism
in the family,
child abuse, abandonment, or
tomboyism
must be the reasons
—because millions of other girls
had
similar backgrounds,
without wanting to become men in
adulthood.
Most of the subjects
had a phase of teen-age sex with males.
Some got married and lived as wives and
mothers for many years
before deciding to become men.
Almost all had a phase of lesbian
identity
(including sex with other women) before
they became men.
After their (years-long) transition to
living as men,
they were much more satisfied to call
themselves
heterosexual men than lesbian
women.
(Some had other self-concepts after becoming
men, such as gay man.)
Most of them found changing sex to become
men
(who could 'legitimately' have sex with
straight women)
a much better self-concept than considering
themselves lesbians.
Most wanted to fade into the male population
—being considered by everyone they met
to be normal, everyday men.
However, their sex-partners knew that
they still had female genitals.
FTM
includes full discussion of all the dimensions
of changing from women to men:
family, friends, psychological adjustments,
new names,
clothes, manners, various hormonal and
surgical treatments,
adjustments with sex-partners, etc.
Because they had lived at least a few
years as women,
before they started living as men,
they rarely went to the extreme macho
position or stereotype.
They were generally known as gentle and
sensitive men.
A
very fundamental
question remains:
Why did these (and other) women want
to become men?
Surely they could have become more stable,
deliberate,
self-confident, decisive, independent,
autonomous,
courageous, disciplined, foresighted, & pragmatic
—several personality traits from the
'masculine', admirable column
of my Gender-Pattern Chart—without becoming
men.
Many women do have these admirable personality
characteristics.
So the desire to become the other sex
must be something more than the desire
for personality change.
Holly Devor does not
believe that the motivation was primarily sexual
(in the sense of erotic fantasies,
for
example).
But we can still ask to what
degree (or
in which cases)
were these women motivated by
their sexual
yearnings?
Perhaps some found erotic
responses deep
within themselves
that told them that they already
were
men,
so they took the courageous step
of radically
changing their bodies
in order to match their imprinted
sex-scripts.
(To learn more about this sex-script
hypothesis, click those
words.)
From this perspective,
perhaps this book could be seen
(at least in part) as a collection
of
stories about lesbian women
who decided to go "all the way"
—to become the-men-they-were in
their
sexual fantasies.
If we understood
lesbianism—especially
'butch' lesbianism—better,
perhaps we would understand
'female-to-male
transsexualism' better.
If we had a thousand 'butch'
lesbians
to study,
perhaps most would have sexual
fantasies of themselves as men,
but only a few would want to become
men.
And perhaps only a small number of
these
would actually take the steps to
begin
living full-time as men.
(However, Holly Devor says that
FTM
is definitely NOT a book about
lesbians.)
Even more broadly,
this book might be a study of
45 individuals who were born as
women
who later decided to live as men
for
a wide variety of reasons.
If we could have each story
separate
from the others,
the various reasons for wanting to
live
as men
might become more clear.
Will better public acceptance of
lesbianism
(and other variations of sex and
gender)
correspond with a decrease in the
demand
for sex-change?
Will some of the people studied in
this
book
later revert to a lesbian
self-concept
instead of thinking of themselves
as
men?
Will same-sex marriage
also correlate with a decrease in
'transsexualism'?
In other words, as same-sex couples are more accepted by the public,
will fewer homosexuals feel the need to change sex?
Here is a basic
criticism of the book,
which can be corrected if Dr.
Devor decides
to do
follow-up studies 10 or 20 years
later
with these same participants:
Each woman-becoming-man should
have a
separate chapter.
This would have improved the
narrative
quality and interest of the book.
And it would have made the
information
better raw material for other
scientific
analysis.
(The author does provide a Participant
Index in the back of the book
that allows careful readers to
trace
all mention of any individual
throughout
the book.
And frequent footnotes tell us
which specific participants are
being
discussed.)
Because the author
is a sociologist, she looked for general patterns,
especially in the family
backgrounds
of these women-becoming-men.
But because transsexualism is so
extremely
rare
—perhaps one person in 100,000—
collecting data about birth order,
childhood
trauma,
family structure and dynamics,
etc.
contributes almost nothing to
understanding
why these women decided to begin
living
as men.
Statistical summaries
and composite stories would make sense
for exploring a phenomenon that is quite
common
—such as getting married or getting divorced—
but when bits and pieces from the lives
of these 45 different individuals
are woven together into a composite
FTM,
many useful facts might have been lost.
Because the author interviewed each subject
personally,
she remembers each story separately.
But we—the readers—might find it
difficult to remember
which pseudonym goes with which story.
The participants in this study might have
had a wide variety
of highly individual reasons for
wanting to live as men.
If so, these special reasons might have
been lost in the attempt
to present a general picture of 'the
female-to-male transsexual'.
FTM:
Female-to-Male Transsexuals in Society
presents only the positive dimensions
of changing to live as men.
Social science will be very interested
to learn
how these new men lived 10, 20, or 30
years after their changes.
(Of course, some of the participants
have already lived many years as men.)
The
study of transsexualism
has been greatly advanced
by this major contribution from
Dr.
Devor.
But this might be just the
beginning
of the
story.
3. Pat
Califia
Sex
Changes:
The
Politics of Transgenderism
(San Francisco, CA: Cleis
Press, 1997)
309 pages
(ISBN: 1-57344-072-8; paperback)
(Library of
Congress call number: HQ77.9.C35
1997)
Pat
Califia has created
the most useful summary to date
of all the facts and theories concerning
transsexualism.
Sex Changes
is based on a careful reading
of the most readily available books
and articles on transsexualism and related
phenomena
—such as transvestism and homosexuality.
Califia devotes chapters
to:
the autobiographies of people who changed
sex
(both the early, well-known books
and the more recent, less well-known);
scientific attempts to understand and
'treat' transsexualism;
problems in the feminist community
created by former men who have become
women
—some now thinking of themselves as lesbians;
the sexual partners of transsexuals;
the political and social movements for
acceptance
of all sex-and-gender minorities.
Because of its
comprehensive summaries
of all the background books,
Sex Changes
is an excellent place to begin reading
about transsexualism and related
phenomena.
4.
Jason Cromwell
Transmen
and FTMs:
Identities,
Bodies, Genders, and Sexualities
(Urbana, IL: University of
Illinois Press,
1999) 201 pages
(ISBN: 0-252-02439-7; hardcover)
(ISBN: 0-252-06825-4; paperback)
(Library of Congress call number: HQ77.9.C76
1999)
This book describes
the lives and problems
of women who have decided to live as
men.
It is based on the author's own experience
and her extensive contacts with a few
hundred
other FTM (female-to-male) transsexuals
—in FTM support groups beginning in 1983,
informal surveys, formal surveys, conferences
for FTMs,
e-mail communications, phone conversations,
etc.
The most concentrated work took place
in San Francisco in 1995-1998.
This book was
originally a PhD thesis,
so it contains comprehensive research
into the history
of women who decided to pass as men for
at least parts of their lives.
However, most of these women would not
be considered transsexuals
by any of our modern conceptions.
Cromwell strongly
advocates the right to change sex
in whatever degree suits the individual.
And this book will be useful
mainly to
other women who are thinking about
living as men.
It is more advocacy and support
than science.
In fact, Cromwell sees the clinicians
who control the sex-change gate
mostly as opponents and oppressors of
her subjects.
She affirms again and again that 'pathology',
'disease', & 'disorder'
are not the correct concepts for transsexualism.
But she does not offer any
alternative
scientific explanations.
However, some
scientific professionals are not hostile
toward people with variations of sex
and/or gender.
It would be good if authors such as Cromwell
would make this distinction
—and tell us which scientific
theories
they like best,
rather than rejecting all scientific
approaches
and affirming whatever mythologies the
variant individuals
embrace at any given time and place.
Usually these
born-females now living as men
made this decision long before they started
any exploration of the scientific literature.
Thus, they often had
firmly-established
mythologies
of their own making, which
explained
(to their own satisfaction)
why they needed to live as men.
And often they cling to their
beliefs
as if they were religious dogmas.
In contrast to
earlier generations of transsexuals,
most of the subjects of this book did
not want to fade into
the general population as ordinary, everyday,
unremarkable men.
Most had only a few surgeries to become
more like men,
such as having their breasts removed.
They often enjoyed their freedom to be
either sex
as suited the situation or that particular
phase of their lives.
For example, some were known as men on
the job
but as butch lesbians
in their social
relationships.
Others wanted to be known in public as
transsexuals
or some form of 'transgender' individuals.
And some even wished to be created
intersexual individuals,
people who were born as normal biological
females
but who later decided to modify their
bodies
to some degree in the male direction.
Their self-concepts
were largely shaped
within the FTM community of their time
and place
—late 1990s San Francisco.
Ten or twenty years later,
they might have different
explanations
of who they are
and new concepts and/or labels for
themselves.
Transmen
and FTMs definitely arises from
the grass-roots experience of hundreds
of born-women
who for a variety of reasons decided
somewhere along the line they wanted
to live as men.
This book is recommended both for
people struggling
with such questions of sexual
identity
and for professionals who are
called
upon to help them.
This book does not settle any
questions
of transsexualism,
but it is definitely an important
part
of the literature about born-women
who want to live as men.
5.
Mildred L. Brown &
Chloe Ann Rounsley
True
Selves: Understanding Transsexualism
—For
Families, Friends, Coworkers,
and
Helping Professionals
(San Francisco:
Jossey-Bass, 1996)
271 pages
(ISBN: 0-7879-0271-3; hardback)
(Library of Congress call number: HQ77.9.B76
1996)
Mildred Brown
is a California therapist
who has spent more than 20 years
working with transsexuals and their families
—more than 400 transsexuals in all.
She remains positive, affirming, &
accepting thru-out.
Brown is convinced that transsexualism
is "a medical condition",
not a psychological or psychiatric problem.
She accepts the belief that transsexuals
were born that way.
True
Selves is written mainly for laypeople
—transsexuals themselves, their families
and friends,
coworkers, & helping professionals
who have dealt with few or no transsexuals
before.
The main chapters cover:
childhood; teen years; adulthood; therapy;
explaining the sex-change to co-workers,
friends, & family;
& medical and surgical helps.
Altho she overwhelmingly
believes transsexuals
who tell her that they were born into
the wrong bodies,
she has encountered people
who have "other conditions and problems"
who are "not transsexuals at all".
She
gives one page
(106-107)
to listing the following 10 conditions,
which do not qualify as
transsexualism:
1. Gay men and lesbians
who confuse
their sexual orientation with the desire
to change sex.
2. Cross-dressers who
discover
that they enjoy the clothes of the other
sex so much
that they want to become the other
sex.
3. Men and women who
are uncomfortable
with the gender-personalities and sex-roles
assigned by society because of their
sex.
4. Men with severe
erection problems:
Because they cannot have sex as men,
some want to become woman.
5. Victims of sexual
assault or abuse,
who therefore want to distance themselves
as much as possible
from the bodies in which they were victimized.
If one result of the sexual abuse is
that
they cannot function sexually as the
sex in which they were born,
they hope that becoming the other
sex
will put all the trauma behind them.
6. Persons who dislike
the behavior
they have fallen into in their original
sex
—eg rape, child-molestation, exhibitionism,
and other anti-social and/or criminal behavior.
They want to get rid of the parts of
their bodies
—usually penises—that have led them astray.
7. Criminals who wish
to change their
identities
to escape capture by the police.
8. Munchausen syndrome:
People who crave medical attention,
even tho there is nothing wrong with
them.
9. Individuals with
psychiatric disorders,
who have delusions that they are
the other sex.
10. Individuals with
multiple personality
disorder.
At least one personality believes it
is
the other sex.
But a sex-change could create serious
problems
for the other personalities.
True
Selves contains lots of practical advice
concerning all of the problems transsexuals
will encounter
in the process of changing to the other
sex:
announcing one's plans to family, friend, & co-workers,
being re-trained to behave as the other
sex,
hormonal and surgical procedures, &
financial problems.
Altho this book
does not advance
our scientific understanding of
transsexualism,
it does deal comprehensively and
compassionately
with
the day-to-day problems encountered by
people
who are changing from one sex to
the
other.
6. Jay
Prosser
Second
Skins:
The
Body Narratives of Transsexuality
(New York: Columbia
University Press, 1998) 270 pages
(ISBN: 0-231-10934-2; hardcover)
(ISBN: 0-231-10935-0; paperback)
(Library of Congress call number: HQ77.9.P76
1998)
Jay Prosser was
born a female but now lives as a man.
The books discussed here
were mostly written
by radical feminists.
Besides advocating the same opportunities
for women as granted to men,
Prosser also advocates the freedom to
change
sex
—or to present oneself as an intermediate
sex between female and male.
Thus, this book grew out of a personal
and passionate involvement
with the cause of sex-and-gender liberation.
The background
research for Second
Skins was a reading
of
some 50
autobiographies of people who have changed
from one sex to the other
—and some important works of transsexual
fiction.
Jay Prosser is aware of the pressure
to fabricate
a standard transsexual story
in order to convince the sex-change psychologists
and surgeons.
And later these stories are elaborated
into full-blown autobiographies,
but still with the purpose of justifying
a sex-change.
Narratives are very important to transsexuals,
first because they must 'remember'
always wanting to be the other sex from
childhood.
Prosser avoids
exploring the psychological reasons
for wanting to change sex.
And any discussion of the
subjects' sexual
orientations,
sexual responses, & sexual
relationship
is mostly absent.
Such an exploration might have
revealed
that most of the butch lesbians
discussed in this book were trying
to
understand
why they have sexual fantasies of
themselves
as male.
Early imprinting of sex-scripts
might
have been a better explanation
in many cases than
'transsexuality'.
A major gap in the research behind this
book is modern scientific sexology.
The author does review old-fashioned
explanations and some Freud.
Prosser traces
the changing models
of these variations of sex and gender:
In the early 1900s, these people were
called "inverts"
—meaning
that they had "contrary sexual
desires";
then they were "homosexuals";
finally some prefer to think of themselves
as "transsexuals"
—and even later as "transgender persons".
In the early
days of 'transsexuality'—beginning in the middle 1900s—
most transsexuals wanted to become completely
the other sex.
When this book was written—at the end
of the 1990s—
a new self-concept was emerging:
"Transgender" people want to make
what used to be a transition into
an
identity.
These persons do not want to fade
into the general population.
They want to be known publicly as "transgender"
—somewhere between the two sexes,
perhaps with the freedom to shift back
and forth at will.
For a while they called themselves "preoperative
transsexuals"
or "nonoperative transsexuals".
And they greatly outnumber the people
who have undergone sex-change surgery.
Transsexual writers
might not be the best people to consult
when trying to create a better
model
for these phenomena.
They might be too passionately
involved
in justifying their own choices.
But at least such autobiographies
provides lots of raw material for
later
scientific analysis.
All in all, Second
Skins is an important
contribution
to the fast-growing literature of
transsexualism
and transgenderism.
In
2014, this bibliography on transsexualism was divided into two files.
Continue reading More
Books on Transsexualism.
In order to keep room for expansion of each section,
the second file begins numbering at 20.
revised 4-24-2009; 9-25-2010;
1-23-2014; 2-27-2014; 5-19-2014; 6-18-2014; 6-22-2014; 4-26-2018;
If
you would like to
read the first-person stories of a few transsexuals,
go the the Transsexualism—Autobiographies
Bibliography.
Related Bibliographies
This
bibliography is related
to several others in sexology.
Here is the complete list:
Sex-Script
Hypothesis
B-SEX-SC
Variations
of
Sex and Gender B-V-SG
I. Intersex
B-CRIT
II. Transsexualism
B-TS
Transsexual
Autobiographies B-TS-AB
III. Sex-Roles
B-ROLE
IV. Gender-Personality
B-GEND
V. Sexual
Orientation
B-ORNT
VI. Cross-Dressing
B-TV
Return to the SEXOLOGY page.
Go to the Book
Review Index
to discover 350 other reviews
organized into more than 60 bibliographies.
Go to
the beginning of this website
James
Leonard Park—Free
Library