Copyright © 2018 by James Leonard Park
Selected and
reviewed
by James Park.
The books are organized by quality, beginning
with the best.
The text in black
presents the basic information about the book.
The text in red
presents the evaluations and opinions of this reviewer.
1. John
Money
Gay,
Straight, and In-Between:
The
Sexology of Sexual Orientation
(New York: Oxford UP, 1988) 267 pages
This book
brings
a truly scientific approach to an area of belief
frequently dominated by partisan and dogmatic
theories
held by people who are certain of the 'truth'
before the research begins.
Money concludes that the research is still
incomplete,
so the question of the origins of homosexuality,
heterosexuality, & bisexuality remains
open.
His research concentrates mostly on people
with sexual ambiguity and/or sexual problems.
But understanding these unusual sexual responses
might cast some light on the more common forms
of adult sexuality.
This book also
deals with the puzzling phenomenon
of transsexuals
—people who believe they are the other
sex.
Cross-dressing (as a costume for a sex-script
and for other reasons) is also discussed.
No hormonal differences have been discovered
to account for different sex-scripts or sexual fantasies.
More research is needed to uncover the possible
relationships among:
sex-hormones; male/female self-designation
("I am a boy/girl");
gender-personality (one's pattern of 'masculinity' or 'femininity');
& sex-scripts (one's imprinted sexual fantasies).
2. Simon
LeVay
The
Sexual Brain
(Cambridge, MA: MIT Press, 1993) 168 pages
Simon
LeVay is the
neuropsychologist who became famous
for a three-page article which the mass media
took up
as indicating that the size of a certain
part of the hypothalamus
causes sexual orientation.
This part is smaller in women and gay men.
Millions of people have heard this interpretation.
But only a few thousand have read this book,
which explains the full facts as known in
the early 1990s.
Based on a small study of the brains of gay
men who died of AIDS,
one section of their hypothalami was on
average
as small as the same part of an average woman's
brain.
So we
don't know
which was the cause and which the effect:
Did homosexuality or AIDS cause this
part of the brain to be smaller?
The science is much less impressive than
the media reports.
And much more research is needed to see if
there is any connection
between the hypothalamus and sexual orientation.
This book
is an excellent
summary of what is known
about animal and human brains—especially
the hypothalamus.
It explains how the various brain structures
affect
sexual behavior in animals—and perhaps also
in humans.
Scientists are agreed that animal sexual
behavior
is 'hard wired' into their brains.
Each species has a stereotyped pattern of
sexual behavior,
which, because it is the same in every member
of the species,
must be transmitted from generation to generation
by genes.
The author would like to find biological
causes
for differences in human sexual behavior,
but so far no biological causes have appeared.
Because
LeVay is
looking exclusively for physical differences,
he has no way of discovering differences
of imprinting.
From the perspective of the sex-script hypothesis,
examining the human brain under a microscope
has no more chance of discovering the causes
of human sexual behavior
than a microscopic examination of the brain
will discover the English language.
If both native language and sex-scripts are
imprinted,
the physical brain must have the capacity
to be imprinted in either way,
but no microscope will ever detect which
mother tongue
has been imprinted into a specific human
brain.
Presumably the imprinting is erased with
the death of the brain,
just as a computer forgets whatever was on
the screen
when the electric power goes off.
So the examination of dead human brains will
never discover
either the English language or same-sex inprinted fantasies.
LeVay
shows how the
body is deeply affected by hormones,
especially during gestation, producing dramatic
physical differences between female and male
babies.
So perhaps the human brain is deeply affected
by its continual bath in sex-hormones, beginning
before birth.
Since we cannot experiment with humans,
we must test this hypothesis on animals.
And it has been shown that changing the mix
of sex-hormones
early in the fetal development of an animal
will dramatically affect the development
of its sexual organs
and its later sexual behavior.
Animal
sexual behavior
is controlled by their sex-hormones,
but nothing similar has been demonstrated
in humans.
So far we know that the hypothalamus is an
important nerve-center
for sexual behavior in humans as well as
animals.
But animal sexuality is entirely instinctive;
human sexuality depends largely on experiences
after birth.
Likewise
the speech
areas of the brain makes language possible.
But these easy-to-study brain structures
do not determine which human
language will be spoken.
Thus, we can certainly learn something about
human language
by examining the speech areas of the human
brain using a microscope.
Future research will learn more about human
sexuality
by looking at the brain areas known to affect
sexual behavior.
But we should not expect either Spanish or
homosexuality
to appear on a slide of a brain section under
a microscope.
More
research into
the brain structures
that make these phenomena possible
will always
aid our understanding.
But to claim that brain science
can explain
either language or human sexual
behavior
is hopelessly reductionistic.
Brain scientists can help
understand the
biological
substrate
for the imprinting of sexual
fantasies,
but they will not find any of
these
sex-scripts
in the brain
—just as they will never find
Japanese, Chinese,
French, or German
in the biological structure of a
human brain.
3. Simon
LeVay
Queer
Science:
The
Use and Abuse of Research into Homosexuality
(Cambridge, MA: MIT Press, 1996)
364 pages
(ISBN: 0-262-12199-9; hardback)
(Library of Congress call number: HQ76.25L497
1996)
Queer
Science is a good summary of research
into the 'causes' of homosexuality:
historic speculations beginning in the middle
1800s;
Freud and his followers; learning theory;
brain structure;
hormones; pre-natal stress; genes.
LeVay is a careful scientist rather than
an ideologue
determined to defend a preconceived belief.
He concludes that the research has still
not found
the 'causes' or 'sources' of homosexuality.
Highly recommended for anyone
interested
in the question of why some people
are gay.
We hope for newer editions of this
book as
the research continues.
4. Marjorie B.
Garber
Vice Versa:
Bisexualities
and the Eroticism of Everyday Life
(New York: Simon & Schuster,
1995)
606 pages
(Library of Congress call number: HQ74.G37
1995)
An interesting
review of
the cultural phenomenon of bisexuality,
drawing especially on well-known bisexuals.
The author
merely collects
the facts and accounts of these people's lives.
There is no attempt to explain why
some people
are bisexual.
5. Stephen O.
Murray
Homosexualities
(Chicago, IL: University of
Chicago Press,
2000) 507 pages
(ISBN: 0-226-55194-6; hardcover)
(Library of Congress call number: HQ76.25.M89
2000)
A comprehensive
survey
of all forms of homosexuality
in every place on Earth and in all periods
of history.
Homosexual relationships are organized into
three categories:
1. Age-structured homosexualities
—in which the age-difference is an important
element
in the sexual relationship, eg an older male
with a younger male.
2. Gender-stratified homosexualities
—in which one sex-partner takes on some aspects
of the other sex,
such as a man being somewhat like a female
in dress,
behavior, hair, language, occupation.
This status as a quasi-woman is part of the
sexual relationship.
3. Egalitarian homosexualities
—in which both sexual partners have the same
sexual status.
The author has
done a wonderful
job of collecting information
from obscure sub-cultures of the ancient
and modern world
that most of us have never heard of.
This demonstrates that homosexual relationships
are found almost everywhere.
But because this is a work of anthropology
and sociology,
rather than psychology or sexology,
the author does not attempt to explain
homosexuality at all.
We get almost no account of the interior
experience of being homosexual.
This book will
stand for
many years as the most comprehensive collection
of facts about homosexuality in every culture
on earth.
Many quotations and a few pictures illustrate
how homosexual relationships were conducted
and understood
in the various places where same-sex relationships
are found.
6. Evelyn
Blackwood &
Suskia E. Wieringa, editors
Female
Desires: Same-Sex Relations
and
Transgender Practices Across Cultures
(New York: Columbia UP,
1999)
348 pages
(ISBN: 0-231-11260-2; hardcover)
(ISBN: 0-231-11261-0; paperback)
(Library of Congress call number: HQ75.5.F43
1999)
About a
dozen articles
reporting on lesbian sub-cultures
mostly in less-developed countries.
Careful anthropological work dealing mainly
with the 1980s and 1990s.
All of the authors are lesbian themselves.
And they wish to show that lesbianism
(and more generally homosexuality)
occurs in all cultures, altho it takes quite
different forms sometimes
—depending on how that particular culture
understands
and explains same-sex behavior and relationships.
The
editors are aware
of the danger
of imposing Western categories (such as butch
and femme)
on the practices of women who had little
or no contact
with Western lesbianism
before they developed their own patterns
of woman-woman relationships.
Each
culture or sub-culture
has its own understanding
of variations of sex and gender.
And each particular mythology shapes the
experience of that sub-culture.
For example, they might believe that a woman
has a man's spirit,
which therefore leads 'him' to behave like
a man.
The
authors represented
in this book seem interested in finding
parallels in other cultures to
their own
sexual feelings and experiences.
But the sex-script hypothesis (not
reflected
in this book)
does not assume uniformity of
sexual imprinting
world-wide.
The imprinting of sexual fantasies
in one time and place
may be completely independent
from the sexual imprinting in
another time
and place.
Almost
universally
women are expected to marry men,
even if they are no so inclined sexually.
Most women do in fact marry men,
even if they have additional sexual relationships
(sometimes with other women).
Some feminists call this "compulsory heterosexuality".
This reviewer calls it simply the heterosexual
marriage assumption.
This book
may be
useful for the raw data it provides
about the sub-cultures
these authors were able to penetrate and
describe.
7. Janis
Bohan
The
Psychology of Sexual Orientation:
Coming
to Terms
(New York: Routledge,
1996)
265 pages
(ISBN: 0-415-91513-9; hardcover)
(Library of Congress call number: HQ76.3.U5B64
1996)
This book
is written
from within the gay and lesbian sub-culture.
It attempts to defend being gay or lesbian
against the oppression of the straight culture.
Janis
Bohan reviews
several theories of sexual orientation,
not finding any of them adequate to explain
the differences.
No consensus has yet emerged among scientists
who explore sexual orientation.
And some of the problems probably arise from the
fact
that we have no clear concept
of the phenomena we are trying to explain.
Being gay or straight does not seem to be
a rigid, unchangeable state of being.
8. Martin S.
Weinberg, Colin J. Williams, & Douglas W. Pryor
Dual Attractions: Understanding Bisexuality
(New York: Oxford UP, 1994)
Three sociologists spent several
months
investigating bisexuals in San Francisco.
They had no theory of bisexuality to confirm or refute.
They just wanted to find out how bisexuals behaved
and how they understood themselves.
Most bisexuals
experienced themselves attracted to both sexes
before they learned the term "bisexual".
And they do not see themselves as in transition
from heterosexual to homosexual
or from homosexual to heterosexual.
But they all acknowledge that society favors
the heterosexual element of their sexual orientation.
In all
relationships, men were more sexual
and women were more emotional.
In this
reviewer's opinion,
bisexuality may not be basically
different
from all people who have more than
one imprinted sexual fantasy.
It just happens that bisexual
persons have sex-scripts
from both of the major categories:
homosexual and heterosexual.
9. Erwin J.
Haeberle &
Rolf Gindorf, editors
Bisexualities:
The Ideology and Practice
of
Sexual Contact with Both Men and Women
(German edition, 1994)
(New York: Continuum, 1998)
266 pages
(ISBN: 0-8264-0923-7; hardback)
(Library of Congress call number: HQ74.B575
1998)
Collected
papers
from a conference in Berlin in July 1990.
Some are better than others,
as would be expected from such a
conference.
But this collection can be read selectively,
depending on the reader's particular interests.
Bisexualities
contains no break-thrus of thought or science.
All of the contributors have
well-established
credentials as sexologists.
A more creative conference could
have invited
people
who identify themselves as
bisexual,
who would attempt to explain their
condition,
responses,
or constitution (however
bisexuality should
be described)
—and what they understand to be
the origins
or sources
of being sexually interested in
both men
and woman.
Milton
Diamond argues
that sexual orientation is genetic:
What causes an individual to be aroused by
a male or a female (or both)
will be found in the neurology of the brain.
He allows, however, that such genetically-given
orientations
are subject to social modification.
John
Gagnon takes
a sociological point of view:
The concepts, labels, & paradigms of any
culture or sub-culture
will shape how sexuality is experienced and
discussed therein.
When more celebrities 'come out' as bisexual,
it becomes chic.
Some women become involved with other women
sexually
because it is 'politically correct' in some
feminist sub-cultures.
If men are the oppressors,
women should not cooperate with them in any
way
—especially not 'sleeping with the enemy'.
And sometimes the emotional closeness of
a feminist group
leads to sexual intimacy.
All
persons interested
in the phenomenon of bisexuality
should at least have a look at
this book.
10. Karol L.
Jensen, MPH,
PhD
Lesbian
Epiphanies:
Women
Coming Out in Later Life
(Binghamton, NY: Haworth,
1999)
228 pages
(ISBN: 1-56023-963-8; hardcover)
(ISBN: 1-56023-964-6; paperback)
(Library of Congress call number: HQ75.6.U52M555
1999)
Based on
interviews
with 24 women from the American midwest
who discovered that they were lesbian or
bisexual
after living several years as heterosexuals,
getting married (some twice), and having
children.
The author's personal history is the same.
This book will mainly be helpful
to other
women
who 'discover' lesbian responses
later in
life.
It is not
a book
of sexological theory;
it makes almost no attempt to
explain
why some women are lesbian or
bisexual and
others are not.
Generally
the subjects
grew up assuming they would marry.
Most knew little or nothing about lesbianism
before they married.
Some report (in retrospect) adolescent experiences
with other girls,
but all turned away from such inclinations
because they believed such feelings were
'wrong'.
Almost
all report
typical problems with being married:
being dependent on their husbands;
lack of communication in their marriages;
their husbands being mainly interested in
sex;
being overburdened with taking care of the
children;
feeling cut off from other relationships.
Many divorced their husbands
before they started relationship with other
women.
Almost all report leaving their marriages
was a liberating experience,
a step toward truly becoming themselves.
The
subjects grew
up with almost no information about lesbianism.
Now that homosexuality is a subject discussed
in public school,
fewer females who have lesbian sexual fantasies
imprinted in their brains
will find themselves automatically entering
marriage
just because all women must get married
as a part
of growing up.
All of
the subjects
report coming out as lesbians or bisexuals
as a discovery of something deep within themselves
rather than as a change in their imprinted sexual fantasies.
In retrospect (from the perspective of their
new lives as lesbians),
all report that they were lesbian or bisexual
thru-out their adult lives.
But it often took them several years to acknowledge
this truth
to themselves and to their families.
One
obstacle to coming
out, according to the author,
was the lack of positive role-models of lesbian
women.
Without the concept of lesbianism,
they automatically dated boys, got married, & had children.
Then, thru a variety of pathways, each had
an epiphany,
in which she discovered that marriage to
a man was all wrong for her
and that her deepest passion was for other
women.
Women who
are thinking
they might be going thru a similar story
will find much support from the
stories of
these 24 other women.
But readers looking for an
explanation of
lesbianism
will have to look elsewhere.
11. Edward Stein,
editor
Forms of
Desire:
Sexual
Orientation and the Social Constructivist Controversy
(New York: Garland, 1990) 365 pages
Eleven
authors attempt
to understand the origins of homosexuality,
some tending toward nature, others
toward nurture.
These articles have all appeared elsewhere
earlier.
The authors tend to depend on library research
rather than original thinking or new scientific
research.
The book is disappointing, but it
is part
of the on-going discussion
among advocates of various
positions.
The sex-script hypothesis would
have been
helpful,
but it is not represented.
12. Alan P. Bell,
Martin
S. Weinberg, & Sue Kiefer Hammersmith
Sexual
Preference: It's Development in Men and Woman
(Bloomington, IN: Indiana UP, 1981) 242 pages
This was
an official
publication of the Kinsey Institute,
which did much of the earliest research into
sexual behavior.
However, this book is now mainly
of historical
interest.
It is based on the faulty
assumption
that family and peers cause sexual
orientation.
(Minneapolis,
MN: Existential Books,
2008) 176 pages
(ISBN: 978-0-98231-561-3)
(Library of Congress call number: HQ21.P37 2008)
This book
offers a new hypothesis for explaining human sexuality:
Each human person is imprinted
with specific sex-scripts
or sexual fantasies during our first 20 years of life.
Our first sexual responses are created
not by nature, not by nurture, but by mental imprinting.
If this hypothesis proves substantially correct,
it will revolutionize modern sexology.
Perhaps
sexual orientation will be explained by the hypothesis
of the imprinting of sexual fantasies before age 20.
revised 4-23-2009; 9-25-2010;
6-3-2011; 4-17-2018;
Related Bibliographies
This
bibliography is related
to several others in sexology.
Here is the complete list.
You can go to any of these bibliographies
by clicking the name:
Sex-Script
Hypothesis
B-SEX-SC
Variations of
Sex and Gender B-V-SG
I. Intersex
B-CRIT
II. Transsexualism
B-TS
Transsexual
Autobiographies B-TS-AB
III. Sex-Roles
B-ROLE
IV. Gender-Personality
B-GEND
V. Sexual
Orientation
B-ORNT
VI. Cross-Dressing
B-TV
Return to the SEXOLOGY page.
Go to the Book
Review Index
to discover 350 other reviews
organized into more than 60 bibliographies.
Go to
the beginning of this website
James
Leonard Park—Free
Library