A scientific tradition
from the Soviet Union offers a good example:
The biological inheritance of acquired
characteristics
was an official Communist dogma for decades.
This system of belief was required by the
party in power
because it fit so well with their social
theories of human progress.
They wanted to believe that behavioral
improvements in human beings
could be passed on to the next generation
in their genes.
Of course, biologically, this is utter nonsense:
Whatever behaviors we develop during our
lives,
no matter how well established,
will not change the genes we pass on to
the next generation.
But this politically-motivated dogma
prevented progress in Soviet biology for
decades.
Lest we become complacent
that such distortions of truth
could never happen in the West, three examples
will now be offered
illustrating how science as presented in
the mass media
led to false conclusions in the popular
mind.
Toxic
shock syndrome
was
in the news for just a few months.
And it led to the withdrawal of one kind
of tampon from the market.
However, the cause of this syndrome
was not tampon design but tampon
misuse.
Women who left large tampons in place for
days,
sometimes caused infections that spread
thru-out their bodies.
Ideological conformity led by media vilification
of just one manufacturer
led to the wide-spread belief that those
tampons were defective.
Silicon
gel breast
implants had a similar history.
Because a certain percentages of them leaked
or broke,
women with such implants
began to blame a wide variety of health
problems
on these foreign objects in their bodies.
But objective scientific research determined
that silicone gel is an inert, non-toxic
substance,
which was the reason it was selected in
the first place.
However, this was not established until
after
several women had already won lawsuits
based on the theory that they had been harmed
by leaky silicon gel breast implants.
And the major manufacturer went bankrupt
as a result of this bad science.
Gulf
War Syndrome
was a similar phenomenon,
this time mostly for men.
The United States engaged in a war against
Iraq in 1990 to liberate Kuwait.
For years afterwards, soldiers who had served
in the Gulf
complained of a variety of health problems
for which no specific cause could be found
by scientific investigation.
Many theories were advanced and the media
convinced the public
that Gulf War Syndrome was real enough
for the Congress to pass special compensation
for service men and women who had the undiagnosable
problems.
But then scientific investigation showed
that
service people who had not
served in
the Persian Gulf
had the same rate of undiagnosable health
problems.
This was not reported nearly as fully as
the original speculations,
so the majority of Americans who remember
the Gulf War
still believe there was a Gulf War Syndrome.
The
Vietnam War
illustrates another mistake of conformist thinking.
In the 1960s and early 1970s,
the United States supported one side in
the
civil war between two parts of Vietnam.
The political thinking behind this policy
was that one side was capitalist and the
other Communist.
And if the United States allowed the Communist
side to win,
they would soon take over the rest of southeast
Asia,
which would be the first step toward world
domination by Communism.
History since 1975,
when the U.S. withdrew from Vietnam,
has shown this prediction to be completely
groundless.
The new Vietnam—while
still controlled by a central government—
has become more successful in commerce than
many of its neighbors.
And 45 years later, still no dominoes have
fallen.
There is no sign of a blood-bath.
The killing stopped soon after the
U.S. withdrew in 1975.
In this example
of conformist thinking,
the American people were divided, even during
the war in Vietnam.
Anti-Communism was the official government
ideology of the United States.
But a significant and vocal minority of
the American people
wanted to end the war by withdrawing
—which
is what eventually did happen.
Open discussion and vigorous
dissent eventually did change
American political and military policy with
regard to Vietnam.
Reason did eventually prevail
against the established forces of ideological
conformity.
And the longest and most foolish war ever
fought by the United States
was brought to an end by the withdrawal
of all foreign military forces.
It will probably be seen by history as the
last anti-Communist war.
And let us hope that it will be the last
example
of how destructive ideological conformity
can become.
Created June 25, 2001; revised 9-10-2010; 11-2-2017; 8-1-2020;
Return to the Flame-Catchers' Handbook.