For this unprecedented collection of Criterion Collection DVDs, it's easier to talk about what's "not" in the massive collection: namely, a few future releases and several films that have had the rights returned to the original studio. But that's only 20 titles out of the 261-title library (as of fall 2004). Criterion set the standard in Laser Discs in the first digital age. Although other studios create some great DVDs, no one has matched Criterion for consistently producing fabulous-looking, extras-laden films on DVD, especially if your thing is classic or international films. The care in print and sound quality is a marvel. Something like the 1932 comedy "Trouble in Paradise" shouldn't look like it was made yesterday. The reconstruction of the original 1928 print of "The Passion of Joan the Arc" is legendary. Subtitles are always new and reexamined for translation; original aspect ratios and sound design are carefully presented.
Being about "a continuing series of important classic and contemporary films," Criterion has developed relationships with many top directors, including Steven Soderberg ("Traffic"), Terry Gilliam ("Brazil"), David Cronenberg ("Dead Ringers"), and Robert Altman ("Short Cuts"). The extras are not fodder from the publicity train, and often outside sources round out the retrospection of the film. What other company would conceive of presenting Truffaut's "Antoine Doinel" series this way? The label is so strong, film mavens often buy the next Criterion disc without knowing anything about it (ever heard of "Onibaba", "The Ballad of a Solider", or the "Orphic Trilogy"?). Either they know they are getting a history in film, or they don't want a gap in the numeric order of releases (plus Criterion discs hold their value better than most DVDs). Either way, this collection is the ultimate way to quickly start your cinema library, be it for your organization, office, or suddenly bigger home collection. As you ponder over the striking cover art or read a printed essay, know this: all classic films--and many contemporary ones--dream of being a Criterion disc. There is no better digital fate. "--Doug Thomas"