CyberHome CH-DVR 1500 Progressive-Scan DVD+R/+RW Recorder and Player , Silver
Would earn a 5, but...
My Windows 98 machine doesn't seem to like the discs this player produces.  It will freeze when I try to access them through Windows Explorer, although other programs will read them fine.  Every stand-alone DVD player I've tested loves them, though.  Quality is great capturing from VHS to DVD, and is amazing when using the TV tuner.  It's easy to use and very fast.  I love this machine and hope to work out the incompatibilities with my PC.