Philips HDR312 TiVo 30-Hour Digital Video Recorder
No Comparison at all, TiVo is the winner
First I decided I needed a new VCR, then I learned about TiVo and Replay.  I went and tried out TiVo, which up until recently, was only available at a store.<br />TiVo blew everything out of the water.  TiVo has more users and  amazing customer service.  I had a question after I was up and running and  they answered the phone in 3 minutes!<br />The 1-800 number for dial in great.   I understand Replay doesn't offer this and it can be of great expense if  you don't live near a local dial in number.<br />TiVo is working with the  biggest companies to provide an amazing future for the company and the  machine...among them are AOL and Time Warner!<br />Because has 30 hours of  time, you can actually use the machine like it was intended, you couldn't  survive with less space!<br />I actually considered Replay, but I didn't know  anyone who had it and I didn't want to get stuck with a technology that may  be gone in 6 months.<br />TiVo is the right pick and Amazon had a great price  and great service.  Speedy delivery too!<br />Go TiVo!