Panasonic PV-HS1000 ShowStopper Digital Video Recorder
TIVO vs REPLAY
I have both units and the TIVO is much better.  The TIVO remote is so much easier to use as well as the screens and navigation.  I find the REPLAY remote far more complicated than necessary.  Both units have the same record time but I tend to use the TIVO more often.  Luckily I paid very little for the REPLAY so it's a good value for what I paid ($200 new).  Even though I pay 9.95 a month for TIVO, I feel it's a better product.