Copyright © 2018 by James Leonard Park
Reviewed by James Park,1. David Kuhl, MD
(New York: Public
Affairs, 2002) 317 pages
(ISBN: 1-58648-119-2; hardcover)
(Library of Congress call number: BF789.D4.K84 2002)
Learning the bad news of approaching death
is often the most traumatic part.
Some were told in ways that seemed worse than death itself.
Some had to peek at their medical records
when the doctor was not looking.
Another patient was told in a drive-by manner:
The doctor told her from the doorway without entering her room.
How should the doctor tell the patient that he or she is dying?
Some
patients want to know only a little piece of information at a time.
But knowing the truth
is usually better than being
kept in the
dark.
We do not want to be 'kept hopeful' by not knowing that we are dying.
The
pain of dying is almost always a combination
of physical pain and psychological suffering.
Everyone wants their physical pain treated.
If physical pain is the overwhelming fact of one's life,
then most people prefer death.
But physical pain can almost
always be managed.
Once the physical pain has come under control,
we can begin to focus on our emotional and spiritual suffering.
We need time to work thru our interpersonal dynamics.
When we are dying, we do not want to be isolated and
alone.
We want to be physically touched.
We want to have meaningful communication
with the people who have been important to us during our lives.
When we are dying, we want to review our lives
to see what meanings we have achieved.
We
want the whole truth about our condition
and the likely course of events from today until the end of our lives.
We do not want lies and
secrets.
We
want to ask "Who am I?" more deeply than before.
Trivial problems disappear when we are facing death.
We often want some spiritual or religious comfort.
At
the end of this book,
Dr. Kuhl tells of participating in the death of
his sister,
which was more intense than the hundreds of other deaths he attended.
But this personal experience has made it possible for him
to offer others some means of coping with the process
of caring for dying people at the end of their lives.
This
book is based on the thoughts and feelings of actual people.
It should be helpful for all readers dealing with the deaths of loved
ones
—and ultimately their own deaths.
There are no philosophical points
to be made.
The wisdom surrounding the
approach of death is simple and plain-spoken.
And this book is filled with
compassion for those who are dying.
2. David F. Kelly
Medical
Care at the End of
Life:
A Catholic Perspective
(Washington,
DC: Georgetown University Press: www.press.georgetown.edu,
2006) 180 pages
(ISBN: 978-1-58901-112-0; paperback)
(Library of Congress call number: R725.56.K46 2006)
(Medical call number: WB310K295m 2006)
This medical ethicist
reviews difficult questions for terminal medical care:
Who makes decisions: patients, family, doctors?
How do we separate standard medical care
(which must always be provided or at least offered)
from unusual, prolonged, questionable, & perhaps futile care
(which can always be challenged)?
How should we apply advance medical directives?
When are hydration and nutrition required
and when may they be withdrawn or withheld?
Are physician-assisted suicide and euthanasia ever wise?
When does treatment become medically futile?
Unfortunately, this book limited its
audience
by including the word "Catholic" in the sub-title.
It is a wide-ranging and thoughtful book
that should be read by everyone concerned with medical ethics.
As a matter of historical accident, the Roman Catholic Church
has created the longest tradition
of thinking about medical ethics at
the end of life.
But this tradition does not limit what the author offers.
He does not hesitate to declare that the Pope himself
departed from wise Catholic thinking when he spoke about
providing food and water to patients in persistent vegetative state.
There is nothing backward or conventional about this book.
David F. Kelly deserves to be much more widely read.
And his writing is good enough to warrant reading aloud.
In the opinion of this reviewer, this book is the best of its kind.
(New York: Riverhead
Books, 1997) 299 pages
(ISBN: 1-57322-051-5; hardcover)
(Library of Congress call number: HQ1073.B96 1997)
A
hospice doctor tells in detail of the deaths of 12
patients
—all
very different, who met their deaths in different ways.
The dying persons are old and young, male and female,
happy as they approach their deaths and having serious problems.
But each death has some important lessons for the reader.
This
book is more about the
psychological processes
of preparing for death than the medical or biological processes.
Even tho each story is told by the doctor,
the perspectives of the patients and their families are foremost.
This
is not a technical book.
Every page can be understood by
anyone
who will eventually approach his
or her own death.
The
hospice team of nurses, social workers, volunteers,
doctors, etc.
is there to help everyone handle this death as well as possible.
Because these helpers have met most situations before,
they know how to cope with problems
that most dying people are facing for the very first time.
4. Jerome Groopman, MD
The
Measure of Our Days:
New Beginnings at Life's End
(New York:
Viking, 1997) 242 pages
(ISBN: 0-670-87570-8; hardcover)
(Library of Congress call number: R726.8.G77 1997)
The biographies of the last years of
ten patients,
including both parents of the author.
Each chapter deals with a different person.
These well-written accounts follow each step
of the process of discovering the illness that ultimately causes death,
including in many cases years
of remission
after successful medical
treatment.
Specific medical details are included,
but each disease and each treatment
is explained in terms that can be understood by laypeople.
This reviewer did not
learn
any new facts about dying from reading this book.
But it helped me to face my own coming death.
If you start reading
this book,
you will want to finish reading it.
Each story is real and compelling.
5. Fiona Randall & R. S. Downie
End of Life Choices:
Consensus and Controversy
(Oxford, UK:
Oxford University Press: www.oup.com,
2010) 220 pages
(ISBN: 978-0-19-954733-3; paperback)
(Library of Congress call number: not in book)
(Medical call number: WB310R188e 2010)
These authors take
a basically conservative approach
to all questions concerning end-of-life decisions.
For example, they are very concerned to avoid "hastening death".
Keeping the patient alive seems to be the default 'decision'.
When discussing terminal sedation,
they want carefully to avoid slipping toward 'euthanasia'.
The purpose of the sedative drugs should be the relief of pain
even if the doctor can foresee
that the drugs will probably result in an earlier death.
These are concerns
mainly for the medical professionals:
Which pathway towards death is most ethical for the doctors?
The patients will probably have rather different questions:
Will I ever return to my home?
Or will I be in medical institutions until I die?
If I am definitely on some pathway towards death,
why choose a longer pathway rather than a shorter one?
If I am ready to die now,
why not shorten the process of dying?
The authors
seem to assume that every patient
wants to live as long as
technically possible.
But at least a significant
minority of patients
would prefer life-ending decisions
that will result in dying now rather than dying later.
Counseling Clients Near the End of
Life (New York:
Springer: www.springerpub.com,
2013) 238 pages Psychological experts, mainly from
the academic world, This book is written from the
perspective of psychological helpers
6. James L. Werth, Jr., editor
(ISBN: 978-0-8261-0849-4; paperback)
(Library of Congress call
number:
)
(Medical call number: WB310C855 2013)
explore many aspects of caring for
dying patients.
Case histories of real patients illustrate end-of-life problems,
including how they were actually resolved in these cases.
rather than the patients who are
facing their own deaths.
But the case-histories are still
the most important contribution.
Almost no attention is given to
making life-ending decisions.
Rather, death is allowed to come
in its own time.
9. L. L. Basta, MD
Life and Death on Your Own
Terms
(Amherst, NY:
Prometheus Books: www.PROMETHEUSBOOKS.COM, 2001)
364 pages
(ISBN: 1-57392-918-2; hardcover)
(Library of Congress call number: R725.5.B27 2001)
A
heart specialist (and cancer survivor) presents most of the issues
that we will have to face at the end of our lives:
definitions of death; medical technology; CPR; assisted dying;
the high cost of dying; cut-off age for medical care?;
doctor-patient relationships; advance directives;
medical futility;
palliative care.
Dr.
Basta recommends that everyone have an advance directive.
He presents his own check-list format,
which covers 4 possible conditions at the end of life
and 4 procedures that might be selected or omitted.
This
is a big-hearted book by a heart doctor.
But it does not break any new
ground.
It could be a starting place for
someone who has not yet faced
most of the end-of-life issues.
10.
Martin Shepard, MD
Dying:
A Guide for Helping and Coping
(Sag Harbor, NY: Permanent
Press, 2000)
208 pages
(ISBN: 0-933256-92-2; hardcover)
(Library of Congress call number: BF789.D4S48 1999)
A doctor who has cared for many dying patients
of all ages
tells of his experiences—and
theirs.
Many of the chapters are extensive interviews with dying patients,
who have a range of different feelings about dying.
This book offers no brilliant new
insights,
but it offers close-up experiences
of the deaths of a variety of
people.
At the end, there is a chapter exploring death as experienced by
the family members,
who continued to live after their loved ones died.
Another opportunity to confront
the reality of modern dying.
11.
David Kessler
The Rights of
the Dying:
A Companion for Life's
Final
Moments
(New York: HarperCollins,
1997)
204 pages
(ISBN: 0-06-018753-0; hardcover)
(Library of Congress call number: BF789.D4K47 1997)
The owner of an in-your-home hospice care service
shares his philosophy and experiences of caring for the dying.
Dying persons should always be regarded as persons
—with all the rights
of persons:
The right to keep hoping, to decide for themselves,
to be free of pain, to express their emotions;
the right to die, to peace, to dignity;
the right to have someone present when they die;
and the right to a decent burial.
Families should be allowed to participate in
the death
as fully as they wish, including children.
There should be no rigid rules about how people must die.
This book provides another opportunity
for ordinary people to think about
death
—one's own death and
the deaths of
others who are close to us.
It provides no new information,
but it is a common-sense account
of the situations we will all face
sooner or later.
12. Timothy E. Quill, MD
A
Midwife Through the Dying
Process:
Stories of Healing and Hard
Choices at the End of Life
(Baltimore, MD: Johns
Hopkins UP, 1996) 239 pages
(ISBN:
(Library of Congress call number:
R726.Q55x 1996)
The process of
dying for nine of Dr.
Quill's patients.
Terminal sedation is the closest Dr.
Quill
is now willing to go toward helping
patients to die.
He became
famous by admitting in print
that he helped one patient to die.
But here we have more mundane
dying-processes.
There
are many useful insights as seen thru the eyes of the doctor.
13. Lois Snyder, JD & Timothy E. Quill, MD, editors
Physician's
Guide to
End-of-Life Care
(Philadelphia, PA:
American College of Physicians: www.acponline,org,
2001) 267 pages
(ISBN: 1-930513-28-3; paperback)
(Library of Congress call number:
R726.8.A46 2001)
(Medical call number: WB310A512p
2001)
See related bibliographies:
Terminal Medical Care from the Consumer's Point of View
Best
Books on Voluntary Death
Best
Books on Preparing for Death
Books on Helping Patients to Die
Best
Books on
the Right-to-Die
Books
Opposing
the Right-to-Die
Go to the Book
Review Index
to discover 350 other reviews
organized into more than 60 bibliographies.
Return to the DEATH page.
Go to the beginning of this website
James
Leonard Park—Free
Library