Selected and reviewed
by James Leonard Park,
existential philosopher and skeptic.
Organized in vague order of quality, beginning
with the best.
Red comments are the
opinions and evaluations of this reviewer.
1. James
Randi
Flim-Flam!
Psychics,
ESP, Unicorns, and other Delusions
(Buffalo, NY: Prometheus Books, 1982)
The
best book on pseudo-science
and claims of the paranormal.
James Randi is a professional magician,
which has enabled him to detect deception
where practicing scientists did not see it.
Phenomena discussed include: astrology; biorhythms;
pyramidology;
Kirlian photography; dowsing; Bermuda Triangle;
UFOs;
Erich von Daniken; ESP; remote viewing; spoon
bending; parapsychology;
psychic surgery; psychic diagnosis and cure
of disease;
Transcendental Meditation; Scientology; &
spirit rapping.
2. Carl
Sagan
The
Demon-Haunted World:
Science
as a Candle in the Dark
(New York: Random House,
1995) 457 pages
(ISBN: 0-394-53512-X)
(Library of Congress call number: Q175.S215
1996)
Yes,
Carl Sagan is the
"billions and billions" scientist
of the popular television series, Cosmos,
which was based on his book of the same name,
the best-selling science book ever.
In this—his last book—he criticizes popular
trends toward superstition,
paranormal beliefs, and anti-scientific thinking.
Some of his major themes: life after death;
channeling—spirit messages from the dead;
faith healing, psychic cures; the role of
religion
in supporting paranormal beliefs and pseudo-science;
crop circles; witches, demons; extra-sensory
perception (ESP);
aliens; satanic cults; horoscopes; religious
visions, hallucinations,
dreaming; pseudo-science in the mass media,
popular culture's fascination with the occult;
pseudo-science in politics and government;
Unidentified Flying Objects (UFOs);
skepticism, baloney detection, fallacies
of logic;
children's natural curiosity about how things
work;
the dimensions of real science: wonder, searching,
hypothesis, testing, criticism by peers,
self-correction;
the teaching and learning of real science
at all levels of the education system;
the use of the mass media for real science
programs.
This
book has more about
the self-correcting methods of science
than the other books in the Paranormal Bibliography.
Careful scientific method—with repeatable
experiments
that allows other competent scientists to
confirm or refute earlier results—
is the best answer to claims of the paranormal
and supernatural effects.
The media should present as much solid science
as they do programs appealing to superstitious
beliefs.
Science and technology
have produced weapons of mass destruction,
which has been used by governments to kill
millions of people.
But science has also produced hundreds of
medical miracles,
which have given us longer and better lives.
Open discussion and democratic process will
allow us to use science
more to enhance life
than to spread death.
This book is a precious
document of our civilization.
It may be seen decades after its
publication
as the crowning achievement of
Carl Sagan's
life.
Will it be one of the break-thru
books that
sheds the light of science
into the darkness of popular
culture?
No prior
knowledge of science
is required to understand this book.
For many years Carl Sagan taught science
to non-scientists at Cornell University and
on television.
This book enables him to carry on that good
work even after his untimely death.
It is a well-reasoned and open-minded book—recommended
to all.
3. Robert
Park
Voodoo
Science:
The
Road from Foolishness to Fraud
(New York: Oxford
University Press, 2000)
230 pages
(ISBN: 0-19-513515-6; hardcover)
(Library of Congress call number: Q175.52.U5P37
2000)
Robert L. Park (no relation
to this reviewer) is a professor of physics
—a practicing scientist—who also attempts
to bring real science
to people who would never otherwise read
a book of science.
The subtitle of this book refers to the very
common progression
from a simple, honest error of scientific
method
to an intentional scheme to defraud others,
usually for financial gain.
The
major pseudo-scientific
frauds discussed here include:
cold fusion—the claim to be able to
fuse hydrogen atoms
at room temperature, thereby liberating the
power that drives the sun.
global warming—projecting dramatic
climate change
on the basis of computer models.
'natural' medicine—miracle cures from
simple substances.
homeopathy—sugar pills programmed
by water than 'remembers'.
magnets—more impossible benefits from
a very weak force.
manned space flight vs. more cost-effective
scientific instruments.
perpetual motion machines—producing
more energy than consumed
by a miracle device that powers itself
as well as produces unlimited power for other
uses.
power lines as a cause of cancer.
UFOs at Roswell, New Mexico.
x-ray lasar super weapon—light beam
powered by an H-bomb.
(Guess what happens: It blows up.)
the misuse of the language and symbols of
science to promote pseudo-science:
"quantum", "uncertainty principle", "vitamin".
The
mass media and politicians
often get involved in pseudo-science
because they do not have the ability to tell
real science
from the exaggerated and impossible claims
of hucksters.
Governments have been known to
waste millions
of dollars
trying to develop something that high school
science knows is impossible.
All in all an
entertaining
and informative book,
which should be read by everyone
who has
been tempted
by any of the foolish beliefs
mentioned above.
4. Michael
Shermer
Why People Believe Weird Things:
Pseudoscience,
Superstition, and Other Confusions of Our Time
(New York: Freeman &
Company, 1997) 306
pages
(ISBN: 0-7167-3090-1)
(Library of Congress call number: BF773.S56
1997)
A
beginning guide to exploring
the following themes:
science and pseudo-science, the psychology
of over-belief,
near-death experiences as proof of life after
death,
alien abductions, witch hunts, Objectivism
(Ayn Rand) as a cult,
creationism, holocaust deniers, & racism.
The book attempts to be
wide-ranging.
Therefore it is brief on most
subjects.
But it gives the reader a very
good start
for much deeper exploration of any
of the
themes discussed.
Easy to read—aimed
at a wide, popular audience.
Many good examples of dogmatic thinking:
First you decide what you believe.
Then you gather all possible 'evidence' to
support your belief.
And you dispute, disregard, or fail to recognize
evidence to the contrary.
That's how people continue to believe weird
things.
5. Michael
Shermer
How We Believe:
The Search for God in an Age of Science
(New York: W. H. Freeman
and Company, 2000) 302 pages
(ISBN: 0-7167-3561-X; hardcover)
(Library of Congress call number: BL240.2.S545 1999)
A
confirmed atheist attempts to explore why other people believe in God.
The God that is either believed in or not
is the traditional Judeo-Christian God—the Creator.
Science can deal with any alleged Creator
by giving an alternative account of creation and evolution.
Besides the supposedly rational bases for believing in God,
there are also cultural and emotional reasons.
A surprising percentage of practicing scientists
nevertheless believe in God.
We
are story-telling, pattern-seeking animals.
And many of our stories and patterns depict God.
But modern science gives a more coherent picture of the world
—and there is no need for a God
hypothesis to explain anything.
Everyone interested in science and
religlion
—from either side—should read this book.
6. Wendy
Kaminer
Sleeping with Extra-Terrestrials:
The Rise of Irrationalism and Perils of Piety
(New York: Pantheon Books,
1999) 278 pages
(ISBN: 0-679-44243-X; hardcover)
(Library of Congress call number: BF773.K35 1999)
Contrary to some claims of rising secularism,
the present time is filled with more beliefs than we like to
acknowledge.
This book turns a very critical eye on every sort of foolish belief
system.
The
United States is supposed to be a secular county,
but almost all politicians claim some religious affiliation.
And they often use these religious connections in their political work.
Books and gurus promoting pop spirituality are sold to an eager public.
People want to believe the optimistic messages,
that we are basically OK and we will all survive death.
Wendy Kaminer serves a very useful
purpose for other skeptics
who have heard of the various
gurus and books
but who have not taken the time to
read these books
or to attend the seminars of the
various gurus.
Wendy Kaminer has done this for us.
And she gives us her useful
reports,
which include details showing the
shallowness and foolishness of pop spirituality.
Millions of people are reading these books
and thousands attend the seminars of the popular forms of
spirituality.
But as we suspected, there is no basis for any of the beliefs.
The books and gurus just proclaim whatever they feel good about.
And the gullible public eats it up.
People seem to want to hear optimistic beliefs about themselves and
their world.
For other skeptics,
this is a very readable and enjoyable book.
But for the true believers,
nothing here will probably change any minds.
7. Robert
Basil, editor
Not
Necessarily the New Age: Critical Essays
(Buffalo, NY: Prometheus Books, 1988) 395 page
An
excellent collection
of essays about New Age history and organization;
reincarnation; past lives; channeling; out-of-the-body
experiences;
UFO abductions; New Age economics and scams;
& intelligent responses to "New Age"
thinking.
Best known authors: Carl Sagan & Martin
Gardner.
8. Martin
Gardner
Science: Good, Bad, & Bogus
(Buffalo, NY: Prometheus Books, 1981) 408 pages
A
collection of essays,
many of which originally appeared in
the New York Review of Books, on a
wide variety
of irrational and anti-scientific beliefs
including:
parapsychology; biorhythms; astrology; Velikovsky;
UFOs; ESP;
magic; psychic key bending; communication
with the dead; faith healing;
Scientology; reading by touch; Lysenko and
Soviet 'science'; & talking apes.
Because these were separate
articles, there
is some repetition.
And the book lacks the coherence
and systematic
organization
of James Randi's Flim-Flam!
9. Martin
Gardner
The New Age:
Notes of a Fringe Watcher
(Buffalo, NY: Prometheus Books, 1988)
A
collection of articles,
many of which first appeared
in The Skeptical Inquirer. Probing,
well-researched, and very critical.
Some themes examined: channeling and Shirley
MacLaine;
magicians passing as psychics; UFOs; fringe
science;
fundamentalists and Biblical beliefs such
as creationism;
perpetual motion machines; spiritualists;
& Scientology.
10. Henry
Gordon
ExtraSensory Deception:
ESP,
Psychics, Shirley MacLaine, Ghosts, UFOs....
(Buffalo, NY: Prometheus Books, 1987)
A
collection of newspaper
columns by a magician and New Age critic.
This book covers all the issues discussed
by JamesRandi's Flim-Flam!
plus several not mentioned in that review:
magicians passing as psychics;
prophesy and ambiguous predictions of the
future; cold readings by psychics;
psychic crime detection; moon and crime-cycles;
fire-walking;
past-life regression; other forms of life—monsters
and aliens;
& science and pseudo-science.
Because each article is short and
independent
of the others,
this book can be dipped into as
suits the
reader.
Might be a good place to start
reading about
the "New Age"
from a critical point of view.
11. Henry
Gordon
Channeling into the New Age:
The
"Teachings" of Shirley MacLaine and other Such Gurus
(Buffalo, NY: Prometheus Books, 1988) 198 pages
A
breezy, popular critique
of "New Age" beliefs by a journalist and skeptic,
who is often called upon to confront "New
Age" gurus in the media.
Gordon deals with crystals, channeling, etc.
The second half is devoted
specifically to the life and 'teachings'
of Shirley MacLaine.
12. George O.
Abell &
Barry
Singer, editors
Science
and the Paranormal
(New York: Scribners, 1981) 414 pages
Twenty scientists, writers,
and other thinkers examine
some of the most popular "New Age" and paranormal
phenomena:
astrology; biorhythms; monsters; psychic
healing; UFOs; Velikovsky;
psychic power in plants; life after death;
Kirlian photography;
pyramid power; lost continents; ancient astronauts;
& the Bermuda Triangle.
Quite a good treatment of several
subjects
of debate
between the occult approach to
reality and
the scientific approach.
13. Susan
Blackmore
The Adventures of a Parapsychologist
(Buffalo, NY: Prometheus Books, 1986) 249 pages
The
autobiographical story
of a young woman
interested in phenomena that seemed to be
beyond scientific explanation.
She tries to replicate many experiments
—but
always with results no better than chance.
She began as an enthusiastic believer but
ended as a skeptic.
Interesting and readable.
14. Susan
Blackmore
Beyond the Body:
An
Investigation of Out-of-the-Body Experiences
(London: Heinemann, 1982)
(Chicago: Academy Chicago Publishers, 1992
—reprint
of the 1982 edition with a new postscript)
Dream-like experiences
in which the self seems to travel
while the body remains in bed are reported
in many cultures,
with different interpretations in each culture.
Careful analysis shows that these experience are dreams,
because they are conceptual in nature.
As in all dreaming, these experiences recombine
elements
of thought and memory already present in
the brain of the dreamer.
No alleged out-of-the-body experience has
ever been able to discover
some fact of the 'place' to which the dreamer
believes
he or she has traveled that was not already
known to the dreamer.
Out-of-the-body experiences move quickly
thru time and space
because thoughts can change more quickly
than bodies can move.
Reading this book will take you
out of your
body.
But when you put the book down,
there you
are,
back in your body, returned from
your mental
trip.
This book is a must read for everyone
interested
in alleged out-of-the-body
experiences.
15. Andrew
Neher
The Psychology of Transcendence
(first edition:
Prentice-Hall, 1980)
(New York: Dover Publications, Inc., 1990) 398 pages
(Library of Congress call number: BF1031.N43
1990)
A
critical examination
of paranormal experiences:
religious visions, ESP, psychokinesis; faith
healing; auras; ghosts, mediums;
out-of-the-body experiences; astrology; UFOs;
& the Bermuda Triangle.
A balanced account—attempting
to find some value in these beliefs
while maintaining a scientific approach.
Because Neher presents each
phenomenon briefly,
this might be a good place to
start one's
study of the paranormal.
There are nearly 900 references in
the back,
showing that the author has done
comprehensive
research.
16. Roger B.
Culver &
Phillip
A. Ianna
Astrology:
True or False? A Scientific Evaluation
(Buffalo, NY: Prometheus
Books, 1988) 228
pages
(Library of Congress call number: BF1713.C84x
1988)
This
book goes into the
science of astronomy much more fully
than other books looking into the claims
of astrology.
The folklore now known as astrology grew
out of star-gazing,
long before astronomy learned how
the universe really works.
So the astrological picture of the universe
is wrong in a number of ways.
And there is no scientific basis for claims
of correlations
between events in the 'sky' and events on
the planet Earth.
Whenever the predictions of astrology
have
been subjected to rigorous scientific tests, they have failed.
This book will be read with profit
by anyone
interested
in the scientific evaluation of
the claims
of astrology.
17. Kendrick
Frazier,
editor
Science
Confronts the Paranormal
(Buffalo, NY: Prometheus
Books, 1986) 367
pages
(Library of Congress call number: BF1045.S33S44
1986)
Best
articles from 5 years
of The Skeptical Inquirer.
Thirty-eight articles by 34 different authors
covering a wide range
of paranormal subjects: parapsychology; ESP
'research'; astrology;
UFOs; fringe archaeology; creationism; &
cryptozoology.
A rich source of critical
examination of
wild claims.
18. Milbourne
Christopher
Mediums, Mystics, and The Occult
(New York: Crowell, 1975)
(Library of Congress call number: BF1031.C53
1975)
An
early book in the school
of Randi and Gardner,
debunking the beliefs of various people who
claim paranormal abilities:
Uri Geller; psychic surgeons; Peter Hurkos;
finger readers;
ESP from space—Mitchell;
Ted Serios; spirit photographers; Arthur Ford;
magicians pretending paranormal powers; the
search for the soul;
life after death; communicating with the
dead; mediums;
Divine Light Mission; Eastern fakirs; etc.
Well written and fully reasonable.
Recommended for those who have
already read
the other books on this Paranormal
Bibliography.
19. Paul
Kurtz, editor
A
Skeptics Handbook of Parapsychology
(Buffalo, NY: Prometheus
Books, 1985) 727
pages
(Library of Congress call number: BF1042.S55
1985)
A
good historical source-book
for the investigation of paranormal happenings.
More than you probably want to
know about
most of the subjects covered.
But a good place to begin to do
detailed
research
in any of the specialized fields
of parapsychology.
revised
9-16-2010
Additional suggestions
sought:
If you know of other good books
in the field of paranormal claims, pseudo-science,
and "new age" thinking,
send details to:
James Park
PARKx032@TC.UMN.EDU
If you liked these
reviews,
there are about 350 more available online.
Go to the Book
Review Index
.
These are organized into about 60 bibliographies
like the one above.
Go to
the beginning of this website
James
Leonard Park—Free
Library