Selected and reviewed
by James Park, existential philosopher.
Listed in order of quality, beginning with the best.
The comments in red are
the evaluations of this reviewer.
1. Corliss
Lamont
The Illusion of Immortality
(New York: Philosophical Library, 1959) 303 pages
A
philosopher examines the history of belief in life
after death,
the religious traditions that include various forms of after-life,
the arguments for and against all such beliefs,
and ultimately concludes that there is no life beyond the grave.
A well-reasoned and well-written book, easy to read and understand.
Lamont draws on science and reason to refute the beliefs in
immortality.
This book affirms life, despite the fact that our lives must end.
2. Hans Kung
Eternal Life?
Life After Death as a Medical, Philosophical, and
Theological Problem
(Garden City, NY: Doubleday, 1984) 271 pages
One
of the most intelligent theologians of the 20th
century
takes on an age-old problem: death.
Kung does not agree that near-death experiences have any bearing on
life after death.
He is well aware of what philosophers have said about death,
what medicine has to contribute to the puzzle,
and even what physics and astro-physics helps us to see.
He is strongest when he criticizes
what soft-minded people say about
life after death.
But he becomes vague in what he
affirms.
Nevertheless well worth reading.
3. Susan
Blackmore
Dying to Live:
Near-Death Experiences
(London, UK:
Grafton/HarperCollins, 1993)
(Buffalo, NY: Prometheus Books,
1993) 291 pages
Of the hundreds of books on
near-death experiences,
this is the one every serious student of the subject
must read.
The author has read all the previous books on near-death experiences.
She concludes that all the phenomena
---separation from the body; seeing a bright light or moving down a
tunnel;
meeting religious figures or relatives; a timeless sense of peace;
a sudden review of one's life; a transformed life after recovery---
can all be explained as products
of the dying brain.
The near-death experience takes place entirely within one's skull.
Blackmore examines (and rejects) such other 'explanations'
as:
alternative realities; paranormal connections;
out-of-the-body visits to another dimension;
mystical vision; and tapping the Cosmic Memory Bank.
The research will continue, but
this book will remain
the definitive scientific book on
near-death experiences well into
the 21st century.
4. John Hick
Death and Eternal Life
(New York: Harper & Row, 1976) 495 pages
A
British professor of philosophy reviews the Western
Christian
and Eastern Hindu and Buddhist ideas about self, death, and life after
death.
He specifically examines immortality (survival of a disembodied mind),
resurrection (a new life in another form),
and reincarnation (a new life in a different body).
Heaven and reincarnation may not be as far apart as they seem at first.
Hick finally invents his own hypothesis of several lives after death,
thru which we might reach moral and spiritual fulfillment.
An interesting and well-informed
book.
5. Ian Wilson
The After Death Experience
(New York: Morrow, 1987)
A
review of the literature about life after death.
Altho the author would like to believe in some form of life after
death,
he comes to basically negative conclusions.
Believing in life after death is only possible on the basis of faith.
Wilson raises a number of
important issues in refreshing ways.
But basically he offers no
fundamentally new insights.
Nevertheless the book is still
worth reading.
6. David
Darling
Soul Search:
A Scientist Explores
the Afterlife
(New York: Villard/Random House, 1995) 193 pages
Altho this book by a
science writer begins with a
scientific basis,
by the end it has veered off into
Eastern mysticism
as the answer to the problem of
death.
Some themes discussed: beliefs in life after death,
ancient to modern---religious, philosophical, & scientific;
near-death experiences; consciousness and self-consciousness;
memory and illusion; perceptions of time and space;
accepting absorption of individual (illusory) consciousness
into the cosmic consciousness.
7. Gary
Doore, PhD, Editor
What Survives?
Contemporary
Explorations of Life After Death
(Los Angeles, CA: Jeremy P. Tarcher, Inc. 1990) 287 pages
Essays on life after death by: Steven Levine, Ram
Dass, Colin Wilson,
Kenneth Ring, Charles Tart, Sogyal Rinpoche, Stanislav Grof,
Stanley Krippner, D. Scott Rogo, & several others.
Most of these thinkers come at the problem with 'new age' perspectives
and various forms of old and new 'spirituality' and shamanism.
Colin Wilson believes in life after death because of paranormal
experiences
such as communication with the dead.
Tibetan Buddhism is well represented.
The book presents no unified
conclusions, but it is a good place to
begin.
8. Raymond
Moody, Jr.
Life After Life
(Atlanta, GA: Mocking Bird Books, 1975)
One
of the first books on near-death experiences,
it offers various interpretations of the phenomena associated with
nearly dying.
People who already believe in life after death will take comfort from
this book,
altho the author is more careful and does consider some alternative
explanations.
Writing almost 20 years later,
Blackmore (#3 above) does a much better
job.
Updated September 2010.
Additional suggestions are always welcome.
Send them to James Park by e-mail:
PARKx032@TC.UMN.EDU
If you would like to
see other book reviews
by James Park,
go to the Book
Review Index.
Here you will find
about 350 books reviewed
in about 60
bibliographies.
Go to
the beginning of this website
James
Leonard Park—Free
Library